v0.19.3 - hotfix: dossier 403 (hidden-page pattern -> options.php parent) (#159)

Dossier registers under options.php parent (stable admin_page_* hookname at
registration AND request time); hide-by-unset removed; enqueue gate fixed;
request-time-faithful regression tests (fail on v0.19.2 by construction);
hidden-admin-page convention codified in CONVENTIONS.md.

QA: REJECT-P1 (ae32876, test file 551 lines) -> split -> APPROVE (6689126).
Verdicts: qa-reviews/prautoblogger/2026-06-12-{ae32876,6689126}.md
Thread: pipeline-v2-phase2-admin seq 21-28

Agent-Session: cto-dossier-403-hotfix-merge-20260612
This commit is contained in:
peptiderepo
2026-06-12 18:41:46 +07:00
committed by GitHub
parent 9c8e500244
commit 5c3328dee2
9 changed files with 681 additions and 131 deletions

View File

@@ -502,3 +502,73 @@ public function my_operation( $input ) {
```
That's it. No config, no feature-flag checks, no try/catch needed.
---
## Hidden Admin Pages (v0.19.3 convention, codified after two incidents)
### Rule: use options.php as parent; NEVER unset/remove registered pages from $submenu
When a WordPress admin page must be accessible by URL but hidden from the nav menu, use the
**options.php-parent pattern** exclusively:
```php
add_submenu_page(
'options.php', // parent: built-in WP page; pages hidden by construction
__( 'My Page', 'prautoblogger' ), // page title
__( 'My Page', 'prautoblogger' ), // menu title (never shown; options.php is hidden)
'manage_options', // capability
'my-page-slug', // page slug
array( $this, 'render_page' ), // callback
);
// No $submenu manipulation. options.php-parent pages are hidden from nav by construction.
```
The resulting hookname is `admin_page_my-page-slug` at BOTH registration time and request time.
### Why the hide-by-unset pattern causes 403 (the incident class)
WordPress computes the page hookname at two distinct moments:
**Registration time** (inside `add_submenu_page`):
WP resolves the parent slug against `$admin_page_hooks`. If found, hookname = `{parent_key}_page_{slug}`. WP registers the render callback and `$_registered_pages` entry under that name.
**Request time** (inside `wp-admin/admin.php`):
WP calls `get_admin_page_parent()` which scans `$submenu` for the page slug. If found, it derives the hookname the same way as (1). If **not found** (e.g., because the entry was unset), it falls back to `admin_page_{slug}`.
When these two hooknames diverge, WP dispatches the request to a hookname with no registered callback → `wp_die(403)`.
**Why options.php avoids this:** `options.php` is a built-in page that WordPress always keeps intact in `$admin_page_hooks` and `$submenu`. For its children, `get_admin_page_parent()` returns `options.php` consistently at both moments, so both produce `admin_page_{slug}`. No mutation required.
### Incident history
| Version | Symptom | Root cause | Fix |
|---------|---------|------------|-----|
| v0.19.1 | Board page 404 | Board submenu registered at same priority as parent (both 10) — add_submenu_page fired before add_menu_page → wrong hookname at registration time | Board moved to priority 11, after parent at 10 |
| v0.19.3 | Dossier page 403 | Dossier registered under `prautoblogger-settings` parent (priority 12, after parent ✓) but post-registration `unset($submenu[...])` removed the slug → get_admin_page_parent() returned false at request time → orphan `admin_page_*` hookname → no handler → 403 | Switched to `options.php` parent; removed all $submenu mutation |
Both incidents are in the same **hookname-mismatch class**: registration-time hookname ≠ request-time hookname.
### Test pattern
The `DossierMenuRegistrationTest::test_request_time_hookname_matches_registration_hookname` test
replicates the request-time resolution algorithm (scan `$submenu` for the slug; if found derive
hookname; if absent return `admin_page_*`) and asserts it equals the registration-time hookname.
This test FAILS on hide-by-unset implementations and passes on the options.php-parent pattern.
Apply the same test strategy to any new hidden admin page.
### Asset enqueue gate
For `options.php`-parent pages, the hook suffix passed to `admin_enqueue_scripts` is
`admin_page_{slug}`. For plugin-parent pages it would be `{parent_key}_page_{slug}`. Always
match the asset enqueue gate to the actual hookname for the chosen parent pattern:
```php
// options.php parent → 'admin_page_{slug}'
public function on_enqueue_assets( string $hook_suffix ): void {
if ( $hook_suffix !== 'admin_page_' . self::PAGE_SLUG ) {
return;
}
// ... enqueue
}
```